If we're talking about paradigm I view debate as a game. IF I HAVE NEVER MET YOU BEFORE DON'T EMAIL ME ASKING FOR EVIDENCE FROM ROUNDS I JUDGEDĪrguments I find offensive and refuse to flow You're not going to be penalized either but it's clear when you have a challenge and when you just get an easy draw in round. That's GREAT!! I'm not going to reward you with speaker points for walloping a weaker team. There are times when one team is clearly more dominant or one student is a superior speaker. I evaluate how well you answered your opponents arguments, ETHOs, persuasiveness, Humor, STRATEGIC DECISIONS. NEW Counterplans in the 2NC I'm not cool with unless the 2AC reads an add on. Over the years debate has been changing and I guess I've changed in some ways with it. I'll listen to K affs or teams that don't affirm the resolution. relevant case arguments, specfic d/as to plans. I love the politics disadvantage, I like strategic counterplans. I don't flow Cross X obviously but sometimes questions and or answers end up impacting my perception of the round. I'm a human being and have lots of beliefs and feelings about debate but I'm persuadable. It's likely that I'll laugh some don't take it personally I laugh all the time and I'm not making fun of you. I did it when I was debating and didn't realize how odd it was. It's weird to me when a kid tries to shake my hand after a round though. I'll shake your hand if it's like your last round of high school debate and I so happen to judge it. I’m sure we can have debates while being tactful and understanding for some folks the issue can be personal. I still believe that debate is a game, educational one however I want to fully acknowledge the serious situation of where we are in our country with policing. I evaluate disease based/ pandemic based impacts much more seriously now due to ongoing effects of COVID 19. Understand if you don’t have bandwidth to support it. While you’re speaking I prefer you turn your camera on. In a situation where I’m on a panel where the other judges are reading the cards I too will as well. I’ve learned that often some peoples explanation of their evidence doesn’t line up with what the text says. MOST ROunds I’m not reading every card on the doc because it’s a communicative activity. What would a topic excluding the Supreme Court look like on criminal justice topic. DONT RUN ENACT EXCLUDES courts in front of me.
0 Comments
Leave a Reply. |
AuthorWrite something about yourself. No need to be fancy, just an overview. ArchivesCategories |